Gruppe Digital

GuidesCosts and planning

Agency, freelancer or in-house staff: who does your marketing?

Sooner or later, many mid-sized companies face the same question: do we bring marketing in-house, work with freelancers or hire an agency? There is no one-size-fits-all answer. This guide shows how the models work, what they really cost and how to find the right one for your situation.

Berke, founder · updated Oct 20, 2026 · 6 min read

Key points at a glance

  • In-house staff know the product and customers best, but rarely cover all specialist areas.
  • Freelancers are flexible and specialized, but need clear management and cover arrangements.
  • Agencies bundle several disciplines, cost more per hour and need an internal contact person.
  • Compare full costs, not hourly rates with gross salaries.
  • For many SMEs, a hybrid model of internal management and external implementation works best.

Why the question so often remains open at SMEs

In many mid-sized B2B companies, marketing has grown historically. Trade fairs, brochures and field sales were enough for a long time. Today, website, search engines, ads, LinkedIn and recruitment marketing are added. Hardly any single person can cover all of this professionally.

Often the task then ends up with someone from sales or an assistant who does it on the side. That works for a while, until the requirements grow. At the latest then, the question arises of how marketing should be set up permanently.

Before you decide on a model, you should clarify which tasks arise at all and how regularly. Revising the website every few years is a different task from managing ad campaigns every day. A simple list of all marketing tasks with estimated effort per month quickly creates clarity here.

In-house staff: close to the business, but rarely specialists in everything

The biggest advantage of in-house marketing staff is their closeness to the company. They know products, customers and processes, sit at the table with sales and engineering and can react at short notice. Knowledge stays in the company.

The limit lies in breadth. Search engine optimization, ad management, web development, copywriting, design and recruitment marketing are each specialist areas in their own right. A single professional will be strong in some of them and remain dependent on help in others.

Then there is the risk of absence or resignation. If one person carries all of marketing, everything is suddenly missing during vacation, illness or a job change. And finding good marketing professionals is often a challenge in itself for SMEs outside the big cities.

Freelancers: specialized and flexible, but demanding to manage

Freelancers usually bring deep experience in a specific area, such as Google Ads, copywriting or web development. They can be used on a project basis, and you only pay for the service actually needed.

The disadvantage: anyone who hires several freelancers has to coordinate them themselves. Someone in the company has to assign tasks, review results and make sure that website, ads and content fit together. Without this management, you get isolated measures without a common plan.

Also pay attention to the legal side. If a freelancer works permanently and under instructions like an employee, this may constitute false self-employment. Under Section 7a of the German Social Code Book IV (SGB IV), the parties can have the German Pension Insurance clarify whether employment or self-employment exists. If in doubt, seek advice.

With freelancers, also clarify cover. What happens if the person gets sick or is fully booked? With running ad campaigns, even a week without management can cost noticeable budget.

Agency: several disciplines from one provider

An agency bundles several specialist areas and takes over the coordination between them. It brings experience from different industries and projects and can absorb absences internally. For companies without their own marketing department, this is often the fastest route to a complete scope of services.

The limits lie in closeness to the business. An agency never knows your product as well as your own people. It depends on someone in the company supplying information, approving content and making decisions. If this person is missing, even the best agency slows down.

Agencies differ greatly in size and way of working. At larger agencies, contact persons sometimes change more often; at small agencies, you often work directly with the people who do the work. So ask who specifically will work on your project and how long you can count on the same people.

The cost logic: compare full costs, not hourly rates

A common error in thinking is comparing an agency's hourly rate with a professional's gross salary. That almost always leads to a distorted picture, because the costs of a workplace are significantly higher than the salary.

For labor costs, the German Federal Statistical Office distinguishes between gross earnings and non-wage labor costs, which include employers' social security contributions, for example. In the company, there are also the workplace, software, training and time for onboarding. Vacation, illness and internal meetings reduce the hours that actually go into marketing work.

With external partners, on the other hand, you only pay for the agreed service. In return, the hourly rate is higher, because it covers the provider's acquisition, training, software and utilization risk. A fair comparison therefore sets the full annual costs of the service actually needed against each other.

Also include the costs of management. If your head of sales spends hours every week coordinating freelancers, that is also a cost factor, even if it doesn't appear on any invoice.

Hybrid models: often the best solution for SMEs

In practice, a division of tasks has proven effective for many SMEs: internally, there is one person who is responsible for marketing, sets priorities and maintains the link to sales and management. External partners handle the specialist implementation.

This keeps knowledge about customers and strategy in the company, while you draw on specialists for search engine optimization, ads or web development. The internal person doesn't have to be able to do everything themselves, but must understand enough to judge results.

There are also intermediate forms on the external side. Besides large agencies and individual freelancers, some providers work with a dedicated contact person who coordinates an established network of specialists. That is also how we work at Gruppe Digital. Which model fits depends on how much coordination you want to take on yourself.

Which tasks are suited to which model

It helps to look at individual tasks instead of marketing as a whole. Some tasks benefit from closeness to the company, others from specialist knowledge and routine from many projects.

Tasks that require a lot of product and customer knowledge and arise daily are usually best kept in-house: coordination with sales, maintaining news and job ads, company posts on LinkedIn, coordinating trade fairs and events. What matters here is that someone knows what is happening in the company.

External support is worthwhile above all for what needs specialist knowledge and is constantly evolving: ad management, technical search engine optimization, web development and data analysis. The platforms' tools and rules change all the time. Those who apply them across many accounts and projects are more likely to stay up to date than a professional who follows them on the side.

Content lies in between. The expertise comes from your company; the writing for search engines and readers can be done externally. A proven approach is for external writers to interview your experts and create content from that, which is then approved internally.

How to find the right model

The following criteria help with the decision. Weight them according to your situation, not according to what has worked for other companies.

If you have many ongoing tasks in one specialist area, there is a lot to be said for a dedicated position. If you have changing tasks in many areas and nobody internally can coordinate, an agency or a coordinating partner usually makes more sense. Freelancers fit well when someone internally is already managing and individual gaps need to be filled.

  • Scope: which tasks arise permanently, which only on a project basis?
  • Specialist areas: how many different disciplines are needed?
  • Management: is there someone internally with the time and competence to coordinate?
  • Speed: how quickly does something need to become visible?
  • Resilience: who takes over during vacation or illness?
  • Knowledge: which knowledge must stay in the company?

What to look for in external partners

Regardless of the model, some basic rules apply. Accounts for ad platforms, web analytics and the website should be registered to your company, so that data and access are not lost when you switch. Agree in writing who owns copy, images and source code.

When choosing SEO providers, Google recommends asking for examples of previous work, the expected results and time frame, and how success is measured. These questions are suitable for any marketing partner. According to Google, anyone who guarantees a number one ranking on Google should be avoided.

Finally, pay attention to the reports. Good partners report not only clicks and reach, but inquiries and cost per inquiry, and they explain what they plan for the next month. A short monthly meeting is more valuable than an extensive report that nobody reads.

Frequently asked questions

When is a dedicated marketing position worthwhile?

When enough tasks arise permanently to keep a position busy, and when knowledge about products and customers should stay in-house. Even then, it usually makes sense to add specialist areas externally.

Are freelancers cheaper than agencies?

Per hour, often yes, but you take on the coordination and cover during absences yourself. So compare the total costs, including your own management effort.

What must be considered legally when working with freelancers?

If a freelancer works permanently and under instructions like an employee, this may constitute false self-employment. The status determination procedure under Section 7a SGB IV allows this to be clarified with the German Pension Insurance.

Who should be responsible for marketing internally?

A person with decision-making authority and a direct line to management and sales. They don't have to implement everything themselves, but they must be able to set priorities and judge results.

Free initial consultation

Where are you losing customers today?

In 30 minutes we show you the three biggest levers for more inquiries, without obligation, and even if we don't end up working together.

Berke, your contact person+49 761 5572 1816 · Reply within 24 hours on business days

Let’s talk

We will get back to you within 24 hours on working days.

Inquiry received!

Thank you for your trust. We will get back to you shortly, within 24 hours at the latest. A confirmation is on its way to your inbox.